Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

15683Re: [gaiapc] Fwd: VIDEOS: 3rd Speaker Series on the Capitalist Mode of Power (2017)

Expand Messages
  • Karl S North
    1 Dec, 2017
      All welcome, I suppose, as part of the perhaps impossible effort to expose the myth culture and reality of capitalism. 

      But it amuses me to see the work of Nitzan and company presenting itself as something new, and repeatedly misrepresenting all previous Marxist social science as defective. My education in this area of inquiry took advantage of a copious literature available to me fifty years ago, developed in great detail over the decades by such as Monthly Review in its journal and many book publications. Hence, my reading of Nitzan yields only minor refinements to the subject. His power theory is standard political economy, nothing new. In Paris in 1960 I read excellent exposées of imperialist capitalism by third world political economists, some of the best in the business, better than Nitzan because they have lived it. 

      On Fri, Dec 1, 2017 at 9:39 AM, Don Chisholm donchism@... [gaiapc] <gaiapc@...> wrote:

      I get regular outputs from Nitzan, but don't often follow up. 

      These talks look interesting, but I'm not yet watched them.


      -------- Forwarded Message --------
      Subject:VIDEOS: 3rd Speaker Series on the Capitalist Mode of Power (2017)
      Date:Thu, 30 Nov 2017 16:26:16 -0500
      From:Jonathan Nitzan <nitzan@...>

      The Capitalist Mode of Power
      Third Speaker Series
      Oct-Nov, 2017

      VIDEOS: http://bnarchives.yorku.ca/ 517/
      YOUTUBE PLAYLIST: https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=qDOMsQT6Eqo&list= PLRDWc3O8rT9jmOpOrmCSCuaelrZ- DZ1jw
      TWITTER: https://twitter.com/ BichlerNitzan/status/ 936342663820869632


      A Power Theory of Personal Income Distribution
      Blair Fix. PhD student at the Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University (blairfix@...)

      Due in no small part to the work of Thomas Piketty, the empirical study of income inequality has flourished in the last decade. But this plethora of new data has not led to a corresponding theoretical revolution. Why? The problem, I believe, is an unwillingness to question and test the basic assumptions on which current theory rests. Most theories of personal income distribution are deeply wedded to the assumption that income is proportional to productivity. However, this approach has a simple, but little discussed problem: income is distributed far more unequally than documented differentials in human labor productivity. But if not productivity, then what explains income? I propose that income is explained most strongly by social power, as manifested by one’s rank in an institutional hierarchy. Using a novel array of evidence, I show (for the first time) that there is a strong quantitative relation between income and hierarchical power. Moreover, I show that hierarchical power affects income more strongly than any other factor. I conclude that this is evidence for a power theory of personal income distribution.


      From Colonialism to Climate Change: The Power to Externalize
      Dr. D.T. Cochrane, Social Sciences, York University (dt.cochrane@...)

      The history of capitalism is a history of externalization. While benefits were tallied, costs were routinely excluded from accounts. In this presentation I examine the history of externalization as a power process. A history of brutality and destruction marketed as innovation and efficiency, externalization has been the shadowy counterpart to accumulation. From colonialism to climate change, I will describe how negative effects of economic activity are systematically imposed on vulnerable communities via the interconnected processes of production and accounting. Finally, I will consider how externalities have made their way back onto the books through uprisings, court rulings and environmental disasters.


      Is the Power of Mass Culture Profitable?
      Dr. James McMahon, University of Toronto (jmcmahon@...)

      This presentation will examine how and why political economic theories of mass culture have accumulated, but not settled, methodological issues about the meaning of value and the nature of productivity. Labour is certainly an important factor to any comprehensive study of capitalist mass culture, but it is our assumptions about economic productivity and not the ubiquity of wage labour that tells us we have to look at the latter in terms of productive output. Therefore, if we use entirely different assumptions, we might be able to create stronger links between profitability and the ideological aspects of mass culture.

      Inspired by Fix’s (2017) and Nitzan and Bichler’s (2017) recent writings on growth and hierarchy, this presentation will focus on the ability of firms to, individually or collectively, negate the potential of creativity. Investment will still involve some type of production, but it can now also depend on the ability of alternative forms of human ingenuity to be neglected, marginalized or repressed by the authority of others. Labour and the costs of production still matter, but the strategies of business enterprise have an authoritative element when large firms can also set the terms of social creativity. Furthermore, this power can be specifically characterized as capitalist power the more we pull away from the assumption that institutional power is secondary or external to the “real” story of economic productivity, however measured.

      VIDEOS: http://bnarchives.yorku.ca/ 517/
      YOUTUBE PLAYLIST: https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=qDOMsQT6Eqo&list= PLRDWc3O8rT9jmOpOrmCSCuaelrZ- DZ1jw
      TWITTER: https://twitter.com/ BichlerNitzan/status/ 936342663820869632


      Recent additions and updates to the Bichler & Nitzan Archives: http://bnarchives.yorku.ca/ perl/latest

      Free to repost and circulate with due attribution under the Creative Commons License (attribution-noncommercial-no derivative). To unsubscribe, reply to nitzan@... with "unsubscribe" in the subject field.

      Jonathan Nitzan
      Politics || Social and Political Thought
      York University
      4700 Keele Street, Toronto, Ontario, M3J-1P3
      Voice: (416) 736-2100 # 88822
      Fax: (416) 736-5686
      Email: nitzan at yorku.ca
      Twitter: https://twitter.com/ BichlerNitzan
      The Bichler & Nitzan Archives: http://bnarchives.net
      EconStor: https://www.econstor.eu/ handle/10419/157759
      Academia: http://yorku.academia.edu/ JonathanNitzan
      Capital as Power: http://capitalaspower.com
      RECASP (journal): http://www.recasp.com/#!blank/ c1m01
      RECASP Essay Prize: http://www.recasp.com/#!essay- prize/cwxm

      Karl North -  http://karlnorth.com/
      "Pueblo que canta no morira" - Cuban saying
      "They only call it class warfare when we fight back" - Anon.
      "My father rode a camel. I drive a car. My son flies a jet-plane. His son will ride a camel."
       —Saudi saying
    • Show all 2 messages in this topic